The four photos
Each file below is the marked input, shown here at web size. The pixel sizes in the text are the files we actually uploaded and downloaded that day. NORDLY is not a real brand. @ourstudio is not a real account. The repeating line reads PREVIEW · HIVEPIC STUDIO because we set it that way.




Every contact sheet uses the same six columns, left to right: marked input, clean base, HivePic, Cleanup.pictures, WatermarkRemover.io, Pixelcut. The clean base is our unmarked original, kept so you can judge the fill. It is not a tool output. On the tiled sheets, the HivePic column is left grey because that full-frame job has no HivePic file to show.
How the test was run
Date: 10 November 2026. Four generated photos, marks overlaid by us, free tier only. We wrote down resolution, rough time, and what the credit counter or paywall did.
A later pixel check against the unmarked original (pixels that moved by more than 30 levels) is supporting evidence. It is not the story. Cleanup’s numbers are the least meaningful of the set, because the free export is a downscale to 720 px.
Times for Cleanup.pictures are about 2 to 4 seconds per stroke, read from screenshots rather than a stopwatch. The other timings are the waits we logged between starting the run and seeing a result.
What came back
Read this as a log of one afternoon, not as a ranking that will hold after these products change their free tier.
| Tool | Free path we actually used | Original size | Date stamp, logo, handle | Tiled preview |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| HivePic | Date stamp without an account; logo and handle after a free sign-in. 3 credits a removal, free download. | Yes. PNG, same pixels as the upload, on the three that succeeded. | Stamp, logo and handle gone, with clean fills. Logo 21.4 s (10 to 7). Handle 24.7 s (7 to 4). | Full-frame tiling is outside the local brush job. No file, nothing charged. |
| Cleanup.pictures | Anonymous, no login across four runs. Each HD upload asked us to continue in SD or start a Pro trial. We chose SD. | No. Long edge 720 px. Outputs were 720×540, 720×540, 720×405 and 540×720. | Marks gone, and the fills look decent at 720 px. About 2 to 4 seconds a stroke. | Only about 20 to 25 percent covered. Most of the text remains, with smears inside the brushed bands. |
| WatermarkRemover.io | Auto-detect, no brush. First two anonymous. Anonymous downloads then ran out. Sign-up offered 3 free credits, no card. Last two after Google sign-in. The counter stayed at 3. | Yes. JPEG at the upload size. Page cap 5000×5000 px. | Marks gone. Closest to the unmarked original. Logo about 7.5 s. Handle re-run about 6 to 8 s. | All tiles gone, 1728×2304, about 8 s. The only usable original-size result on the free web path. |
| Pixelcut | Magic Eraser, brush only. /watermark-remover was a 404. Anonymous download was a 1080 preview. Full size after a free Google sign-in. Daily downloads nearly used up after four files. | Yes, after sign-in. JPEG at the upload size. Cap shown: 50 MB or 6000×6000. | Marks gone in about 2 seconds. Faint yellow tint on the mug edge. Foliage fill is the blurriest of the four. | Large brush turned the frame dark grey. Smaller brush left text fragments and warped the latte, notebook and pencil. |
| Fotor | Did not run. New account showed 0 credits. Remove costs 4 credits and opened a Pro trial (US$3.99/mo, billed yearly, 7 days free) that we did not start. | No output. | Not tested. Their FAQ promised free credits once on registration. This account did not get them. | Not tested. Their marketing sliders are shown separately and are not our files. |
| Inpaint | No free web tool. Desktop trial not installed. The 1-year license at $29.99 was not bought. | No output. | Not tested. | Not tested. Their site collage is marketing, shown separately. |
The sheets are crops of the mark, except the first tiled figure, which is the full frame. Open them wide enough to see the fill.
Travel date stamp
Orange seven-segment date, 2019.08.14, bottom right, sitting on sand. Upload size 2304×1728.
All four tools that ran removed the stamp and did not add a watermark of their own. HivePic rebuilt the sand cleanly at the full 2304×1728, and the patch reads as sand. Cleanup.pictures looks fine inside its 720×540 export, which is the limit of that free path. WatermarkRemover.io also stayed close to the unmarked sand. Pixelcut’s patch is a little soft.
We ran the date stamp without an account, which used that day’s 3 free credits, and downloaded the result after signing in. Signing in did not charge it again.

Old logo on a mug
Fictional NORDLY wordmark and star, deep teal, lower left, overlapping the oak table and the mug’s edge. Upload size 2304×1728.
HivePic, one pass: 21.4 seconds, 3 credits (10 to 7 for a new signed-in user), output 2304×1728 PNG. The wordmark and icon are gone. The wood grain and the mug’s lower-left edge are rebuilt cleanly, with no obvious smear.
WatermarkRemover.io, still anonymous: about 7.5 seconds, 2304×1728 JPEG, mark gone, including the part that crossed the mug. This was the closest of the four to the unmarked original.
Pixelcut, after a free Google sign-in, full resolution: the logo is gone in about 2 seconds. The mug edge where the mark overlapped is slightly soft and carries a faint yellow tint.
Cleanup.pictures: one stroke, about 3 to 4 seconds, mark gone, 720×540. At that size the mug edge looks clean. It is not an original-resolution file.

Platform handle on a video still
A generated park still, the kind of frame you export from a phone video: a dog running, and a white @ourstudio icon plus handle in the top left, over foliage. Upload size 2560×1440. HivePic does not edit video. This was a still, treated as a photo.
All four removed the handle. The foliage is where they separate. Pixelcut’s fill is visibly blurry and smeared against the sharper leaves around it. That was the weakest foliage of the four, at 2560×1440, in about 2.7 seconds.
HivePic: 24.7 seconds, 3 credits (7 to 4 on that same 10-credit daily allowance), 2560×1440 PNG. The branches are rebuilt naturally, and the changes stayed inside the top-left patch we brushed, so the dog and the rest of the frame are untouched.
WatermarkRemover.io: we re-ran this one after sign-in and did not keep the earlier anonymous card, because that download had been blocked. About 6 to 8 seconds, 2560×1440 JPEG, handle gone, foliage slightly soft.
Cleanup.pictures: handle gone, 720×405, a slightly smoothed patch of leaves. Usable only if that size is acceptable.

Tiled client preview
The hard case. PREVIEW · HIVEPIC STUDIO, repeated on a diagonal across a cafe flat-lay, about 31 percent opacity. Upload size 1728×2304. A brush has very little clean background left to copy from, and a large mask is a different problem from a date stamp.
Only WatermarkRemover.io produced a usable original-resolution result on the free web path. One automatic pass, about 8 seconds, 1728×2304 JPEG, no new watermark. The tiles are gone. Marble, linen, the glass and the shadows stay put. Against our unmarked original it is nearly a match: about 0.01 percent of pixels moved by more than 30 levels, and the average absolute difference was under 1 level. That is a reconstruction of the tiles, not a repaint of the scene.
HivePic’s brush remover is built for local marks like the three above. A mask over nearly the whole frame is a different job, and that run gave us no file to show. It also did not charge anything, so the daily balance stayed at 4 of 10.
Cleanup.pictures never covered the frame. A zigzag drag registered as diagonal bands, roughly 20 to 25 percent of the tile. Inside those bands the letters break up into smears, ghosts and stubs. Most of the preview text is still there. The free export is 540×720.
Pixelcut, first attempt: a large brush (size 55, about 85 percent of the frame) finished in about 2 seconds and turned the whole picture dark grey. We did not download it. The screenshot is that failure.
Pixelcut, second attempt, from a fresh upload: a smaller brush (size 24, about 75 percent of the frame), about 2 seconds, 1728×2304 JPEG. Fragments of PREVIEW and HIVEPIC STUDIO remain. The latte art is destroyed, the notebook and pencil warp, and the croissant, plate and napkin textures change. More than 13 percent of pixels moved by more than 30 levels versus the unmarked original. Not a file we would send.
On a mark repeated across the whole frame, automatic detection mattered more than brushing.





The free path was part of the result
HivePic charges 3 credits a removal. Downloads were free, with no HivePic watermark on the file, and results are deleted after 7 days. Without an account you get 3 credits a day, which is one removal; that is how we ran the date stamp. A new signed-in user gets 10 credits a day. The logo and the handle used 3 each, leaving 4 of 10, and nothing is charged when a run returns no file.
WatermarkRemover.io detects the mark. There is no brush. The control we used was the default fast remove (Pixelbin). Images 1 and 2 ran anonymously at full size. Around the fourth download the anonymous allowance ran out. Sign-up offered 3 more free credits and did not ask for a card. Images 3 and 4 ran after a Google sign-in. The avatar menu showed “Credit Left: 3” before those two runs and still showed 3 after them. We are not calling signed-in use unlimited. The counter simply did not move on the two runs we did. The page states a 5000×5000 px upload cap. No new watermark on the downloads.
Pixelcut’s watermark URL, /watermark-remover, was a 404. The eraser we used is the Magic Eraser at pixelcut.ai/cleanup-pictures (Retouch, then Erase). Brush only. The landing banner said free HD download and no watermark. An anonymous download of the date stamp was offered as a 1080 preview; full resolution required sign-in. A new free account via Google, no card, was enough. About 2 seconds per erase. After four full-resolution downloads the daily counter was nearly exhausted (it showed 1 download left before the last file). Upload cap shown: 50 MB or 6000×6000.
Fotor’s Magic Eraser, Watermark tab, did not run on any of the four files. Sign-in was required. A new Google account showed 0 credits. Remove was priced at 4 credits and opened a Pro trial: US$3.99 a month, billed yearly, due today US$0, 7 days free. We closed it. Their FAQ says every registered user gets free credits once. That did not match this account on this day. We have no Fotor output of our photos.
Inpaint (theinpaint.com) has no free web editor. /online and /buy returned 404. /download offers a free-trial installer for Windows 8 or later and macOS 10.14 or later, and there is an iOS app. /order sells a 1-year license at $29.99: unlimited images, original resolution, one year of updates. Bundles were listed at $49.98 and $84.95. The pages we saw did not say whether a trial export is watermarked or whether save is disabled. We did not install the trial or buy the license. None of the four photos were run.
Official marketing, kept separate
Fotor and Inpaint publish before-and-after pictures of date stamps, handles and tiled text. Those frames are their marketing. They were not made by running our files, and they are not evidence of how either tool would have treated the four photos above. We are showing them so the access wall is not mistaken for a hidden success.







What we would do with the next file
For an everyday date stamp, an old logo, or a platform handle, HivePic is the one we would open first: you brush only the mark, the rest of the photo stays untouched, the PNG comes back at the original pixel size with no new watermark, and the download is free. WatermarkRemover.io and Pixelcut after a free sign-in also kept the original size. Pick Cleanup.pictures only when a 720 px file is enough.
A full-frame tiled preview is a separate job. On that file, WatermarkRemover.io’s automatic pass gave the cleanest free result. Pixelcut’s large brush destroyed the frame and the smaller brush left text and warped the objects. Cleanup.pictures left most of the tile in place.
Count the free allowance too. HivePic gives one removal a day without an account and 10 credits a day after a free sign-in, enough for three removals, and a run that returns no file costs nothing. WatermarkRemover.io stopped anonymous downloads, then offered 3 free credits with no card. Pixelcut’s full size needs a free sign-in and has a small daily download cap. Fotor’s new account had 0 credits against an FAQ that promised free credits once. Inpaint is a desktop trial and a $29.99 year, not a web page.
If the job is a date stamp, your own logo, or a handle on a still you are allowed to edit, HivePic did all three here at original size for 3 credits each, with a free download and no added watermark. New users get 10 credits a day after a free sign-in.
These samples, and the photos you should not touch
The four source photos were generated for this test. We have the rights to them. Every mark — the date stamp, the NORDLY wordmark, the @ourstudio handle, and the PREVIEW · HIVEPIC STUDIO tile — was overlaid by us. Do not read the sheets as client work, and do not read the vendor sliders further down as our results.
HivePic’s terms limit watermark, text and object removal to images you own or are allowed to modify. The ordinary cases are your own camera date stamp, your own old logo on your own product photo, and a caption you added. If you are unsure, leave the mark.
Free tiers move. Everything dated above is what we saw on 10 November 2026, on these four files, on the free path. If a price or a credit count matters before you pay, read the checkout screen that day.